logo naukrinama

Supreme Court to Revisit CBSE's Three-Language Policy Exemption for Class 6

The Supreme Court is set to reconsider the CBSE's exemption from the three-language policy for Class 6 students, following a request from the board. CBSE argues that the exemption affects a small percentage of students and has led to confusion in academic standards. The board has presented data showing that the majority of Class 6 students are already learning two Indian languages. The court's decision will clarify the implications of this policy change amidst concerns from parents and educators. Stay tuned for updates on this significant educational issue.
 

Supreme Court Hearing on CBSE's Language Policy



The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) has approached the Supreme Court with a request to overturn its order from September 28, which allowed Class 6 students to be exempt from the three-language policy for the current academic year.


CBSE argues that this exemption affects less than 1% of Class 6 students in schools affiliated with the board across the country, particularly those studying a foreign language. The board believes that this exemption has led to confusion regarding the academic standards established in its affiliated institutions.


During the proceedings, Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati, representing the Central Government, sought an expedited hearing before a bench led by Justice Surya Kant, emphasizing the need for clarification on certain issues. The Supreme Court has agreed to hear the case in the upcoming week.


Understanding the Dispute

The controversy arose after the introduction of the three-language policy for Class 6 as part of the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020. Some states and parents challenged this policy, claiming that its implementation mid-academic year has caused confusion and raised concerns about the availability of textbooks and qualified teachers. On September 28, the Supreme Court noted that since students in Classes 7, 8, and 9 were already exempt from this policy, it would be reasonable to extend the same exemption to Class 6 students. In its defense, the CBSE stated that for many years, even before the three-language policy was introduced, schools affiliated with it have been teaching two Indian languages in grades 6 to 8, while the concept of a 'third language' was only introduced this year for Class 9.


CBSE's Data-Driven Argument

To bolster its case, the CBSE provided comprehensive data regarding its affiliated schools and student demographics. The board oversees 33,017 schools with a total enrollment exceeding 27.5 million (2.75 crore) students. Specifically, Class 6 enrollment across CBSE schools surpasses 2.324 million (23.24 lakh). Notably, over 2.34 million (23.4 lakh) students are already engaged in learning two Indian languages. There are 99 CBSE schools where students are studying two foreign languages, with 4,186 students enrolled in these programs, while 19,892 students are learning two Indian languages. The CBSE highlighted that the number of students opting for two foreign languages has decreased to 4,186, in contrast to approximately 45,000 students who have chosen two Indian languages. The board contends that granting an exemption solely to accommodate the 4,186 students studying foreign languages would be unjust to the 45,000 students who have opted for Indian languages, utilizing the resources available at their schools.


Textbook and Teacher Availability

Addressing concerns about potential shortages of textbooks and teachers, the CBSE reassured the court that textbooks for the 'third language'—which includes all 22 scheduled Indian languages—are accessible through the NCERT for Class 6. These resources cater to the needs of over 98% of schools. For other languages, schools can utilize relevant SCERT textbooks and materials. Furthermore, a survey of 20,777 schools revealed that approximately 93% have teachers qualified to teach at least two different languages, with 3,523 of these schools having educators capable of teaching three or more Indian languages.