logo naukrinama

Bombay High Court Sets Strict Limits on MBBS First Year Attempts

The Bombay High Court has established a strict limit of four attempts for MBBS first-year students, emphasizing that exceeding this limit can lead to expulsion from the program. This ruling arose from a case involving a student who failed to pass the Anatomy exam within the allowed attempts. The court clarified that the regulations apply uniformly to all students, and no additional attempts will be granted. With the MBBS course spanning 5.5 years, including a mandatory internship, students must navigate these new rules carefully to ensure their academic success. This article delves into the implications of this ruling and offers advice for medical students on managing their studies effectively.
By Ambika Singh Sep 7, 2026, 16:04 IST

Understanding the New Rules for MBBS First Year Attempts


New Regulations for MBBS Students: Each year, a large number of candidates clear the NEET-UG exam, aspiring to gain admission into prestigious government medical institutions. However, only a small fraction achieves this goal. It's crucial to note that even after securing a place in a medical college, a student's admission can be revoked. A recent ruling from the Bombay High Court has issued a significant warning to those pursuing a medical career.


This case centers around a female student who enrolled at the Maharashtra University of Health Sciences (MUHS) in August 2023. Despite her commendable NEET score, she exceeded the allowed time to finish her first-year MBBS studies. She passed all internal assessments except for Anatomy, which she failed to clear in the theory exam, resulting in the university preventing her from taking further examinations. The situation escalated to the Bombay High Court.


Key Ruling from the Bombay High Court: Maximum of Four Attempts for MBBS First Year
A bench led by Justice Firdosh P. Pooniwalla and Justice R.I. Chagla took a firm stance during the hearing. The Court stated that an MBBS student is permitted a maximum of four attempts to pass the first year, regardless of the subjects taken or missed during those attempts.


Student's Defense and Court's Decision:


The student argued that she had only attempted the 'Anatomy' paper three times, thus believing she deserved a fourth chance. However, the High Court rejected her petition, referencing Regulation 21 of the National Medical Commission's (NMC) 'Graduate Medical Education Regulations, 2023'. The court emphasized that the regulations are uniformly applicable, and no additional attempts can be granted once the four attempts are exhausted.


Duration and Regulations of the MBBS Course:
Total Duration: The MBBS program in India lasts 5.5 years, which includes 4.5 years of academic coursework followed by a one-year mandatory rotating internship.
Maximum Time Limit: As per the NMC's 2023 amendments, students have a maximum of 10 years to complete their MBBS degree, including the internship.
First Year Regulations: Despite the overall 10-year limit, students are restricted to four attempts to clear the first year. Failure to do so results in expulsion from the MBBS program.


Advice for Aspiring Medical Students:
1. Understand Attempt Counting: Each exam taken in the first year counts as one attempt. You do not receive four attempts for each subject.
2. Seek Remedial Classes Promptly: If you find yourself struggling with subjects like Anatomy or Biochemistry, promptly request additional support from your professors.


FROM AROUND THE WEB